Listen to the blog here.
I was gonged off the practice stage three minutes into my five-minute story. I could feel the heat in my cheeks and the indignation towards the teacher. Did he not realize that telling stories is my thing?
I was in a speaker training program, and that day we were practicing different tools to vary our speaking style - from a rant to a joke to a statistic stack. This particular exercise was the soft disclosure story - the “why me?” story that should be in every keynote speech. I was certain I had this activity nailed since I teach storytelling workshops. I was thinking ahead to the kudos I would receive about my story that perfectly illustrates my point about the power of story.
I stood in front of the room, thinking about my newly acquired skills to command the space, and I began at the beginning: the postcard that arrived in my mailbox about a conference. How difficult it was to say yes. The imposter syndrome that crept in as the date got closer. I was still setting the context, still a long way from the moment that made my point, and that, my friends, is when I got the gong.
I was so upset I took myself for a walk outside to go through a few stages of grief. I don’t know them all, but shortly after I had awareness, I realized I could do better. And this is where I learned some new things about great stories.
Backstory is not setup. It’s the answer to a question. A good story starts as close to the action, or the transformation, as possible. Get your reader or listener curious first. Then use backstory to answer the questions your opening just raised.
Some call it the Law and Order Effect, said literary agent Jessica Berg, in a class on writing. Skip the warm-up and go straight to the body at the crime scene.
Now, I flip the script. My story starts at that conference, at the moment I’ve been called to the stage to introduce myself, even though I intended to remain anonymous. I connect back to receiving the postcard, why I decided to attend, and why I wanted to be anonymous.
Now that listeners have become curious about my opening line, and I’ve answered the questions on their minds, they are bought in. I then show the impact my introduction had and wonder aloud what would have happened if I had not told my story (the stakes) and instead remained anonymous as I had intended to. At that point, each member in the audience can connect their own experience to my story.
Three examples of where our stories can go wrong
You introduce your organization by saying what year it was founded, and bring the listener up to “today, we …..” (My favorite is when nonprofits give their actual nonprofit tax status along with the year they were founded. Gripping storytelling!)
The board presentation that opens with three slides of history is hard to follow. No one is grounded in purpose, and their attention begins to wander. When it comes time to move big decisions forward, your skeptics are still skeptical.
The guy who holds up the Zoom introductions with a long-winded version of his “why” story that starts when he was six years old.
Try this instead
You are not a bad storyteller; you just stopped working on it too soon. Better stories come with better editing.
For your next presentation, get everything out first, onto the page or into your slides, however you work. Then get ruthless by asking yourself the hard questions. Where’s the action? What moment are you building toward? What key decision needs to be made and what’s at stake today? Get as close to the crime scene as you can. (No, I’m not comparing your organization to a body in the living room.) Simply put - what would happen if you cut the first three paragraphs or slides and moved them later?
Once you identify the key moment, it becomes your north star and guides which details in the backstory you need to describe now. The difference is, you have everyone’s attention first. You have their curiosity.
Every story you tell next year can and should get buy-in. But first you need their attention. Done well, your stories can change minds and shift perspectives. I can help you do that on January 12!
I’m hosting The 12 Stories of 2027 and I’d love for you to join me:
You’ll leave with:
Your Twelve Stories plan: a one-page plan tied to your goals and the moments already on your calendar.
Your first story, drafted and ready to be tested with people close to you.
Story prompts - for the stories every leader should be telling in 2027.
90 minutes with me live, in a small group for $47.
Take care out there.